Listen to this Post
Cortex XSIAM from Palo Alto Networks has been reported to lack essential features for case management, reporting, orchestration, and automation. Security professionals have expressed frustration over missing functionalities such as:
– Data validation
– Custom field reporting
– Programmatic triggers based on field changes
Several alternatives and workarounds have been suggested by experts in the field, including custom-built solutions and open-source platforms.
You Should Know: SOAR Alternatives and Workarounds
1. Custom Case Management with Jira & SOAR
Sourov Zaman shared their approach:
- Jira as a case management layer
- Structured database for data integrity
- SOAR integration for workflow automation
Example Commands for Automation:
Trigger Jira ticket updates via REST API
curl -X PUT -u "user:api_token" -H "Content-Type: application/json" \
"https://your-domain.atlassian.net/rest/api/2/issue/ISSUE-KEY" \
-d '{"fields":{"customfield_12345":"New Value"}}'
Log changes in a structured database (PostgreSQL example)
psql -h your-db-host -U user -d db_name -c \
"UPDATE cases SET status='investigating' WHERE case_id='123';"
2. Tracecat – Open-Source SOAR Alternative
Chris L. (Tracecat co-founder) highlighted:
- Schema validation via Pydantic
- YAML-based no-code workflows
- Lookup tables for tracking field changes
Installation & Example Workflow:
Clone Tracecat repository git clone https://github.com/TracecatHQ/tracecat.git cd tracecat Run with Docker docker-compose up -d Example YAML workflow snippet workflows: - name: "Field Change Trigger" actions: - name: "validate_input" type: "pydantic_validation" schema: "CaseSchema"
3. Splunk Phantom (Now Splunk SOAR)
For enterprise users, Splunk SOAR offers:
- Custom playbooks
- Dynamic field updates
- Integration with SIEMs
Example Phantom Playbook Code:
def on_field_change(container, field):
if field == "severity" and container["severity"] == "High":
execute_action("notify_team", container_id=container["id"])
What Undercode Say
The limitations of Cortex XSIAM highlight the need for flexible SOAR solutions. Open-source tools like Tracecat and custom integrations with Jira or Splunk provide viable alternatives. Key takeaways:
– Automate case management with scripting (Bash/Python).
– Track field changes using databases or lookup tables.
– Use schema validation (Pydantic, JSON Schema) for data integrity.
Relevant Linux/Windows Commands for SOAR Automation:
Linux: Monitor log changes (trigger actions)
tail -f /var/log/soc/alerts.log | while read line; do
if [[ "$line" == "CRITICAL" ]]; then
python3 /opt/soar/trigger_playbook.py --event "$line"
fi
done
Windows: PowerShell script for event-triggered automation
Register-WmiEvent -Query "SELECT FROM __InstanceModificationEvent WHERE TargetInstance ISA 'Win32_Process'" \
-Action { Invoke-RestMethod -Uri "http://soar-api/trigger" -Method POST }
Prediction
As enterprises demand more customizable SOAR solutions, open-source and hybrid platforms (like Tracecat) will gain traction. Palo Alto may eventually enhance XSIAM, but third-party tools will bridge the gap in the short term.
Expected Output:
A detailed guide on SOAR alternatives with practical code snippets, automation techniques, and predictions on future trends in security orchestration.
Relevant URLs:
References:
Reported By: Activity 7327750598794133505 – Hackers Feeds
Extra Hub: Undercode MoN
Basic Verification: Pass ✅
